Here's the list so far:
1. John Matrix (Commando)
2. Dalton (Road House)
3. Hannibal Lector (Silence of the Lambs)
4. Beck (The Rundown)
5. Antonov Navarre (Ladyhawke)
6. Ash (Evil Dead 1,2,3)
7. James Bond
8. Conan (Conan The Barbarian)
9. Jack Sparrow (Pirates Of The Caribbean)
10. The Man With No Name (The Good, The Bad and the Ugly)
11. Chen Zhen (Fist of Legend) - Jet Li
12. Dutch (Predator)
13. Rambo (Rambo: First Blood Part II)
14. Thomas (Wheels on Meals) - Jackie Chan
15. Ivan Drago (Rocky IV)
16. John Connor adult (T2 opening)
For the record, as much as I love McClane, I'd take Riggs in any sort of fight with him. Unless they had a smirk-off.
Rob, I didn't add John Wayne to the list because you didn't specify a movie. Just pick one for your next round of guess. We should probably cap them off at 32, unless everyone wants more and we'll just go up to 64.
My next 4:
17. Lee (Enter the Dragon) - Bruce Lee
18. Achilles (Troy)
19. Leonidas (300)
20. Nada (They Live)