Thread: I am legend
View Single Post
Old 05-11-2008   #99 (permalink)
Kinzdone
MovieForums Extra
 
Kinzdone's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Perth, Western Australia
Posts: 441
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by marvelous View Post
I think I Am Legend was a good film. I didn't like the ending though, Robert Neville shouldn't have died. Thank God for the alternate ending. I also welcome the fact that the setting of I Am Legend was transferred to New York. And Will Smith played the role perfectly, i honestly couldn't picture Arnold Schwarzenegger to pull it off as well as Will did.
Neville dying was a great ending, self sacrifice for the greater good. Not enough films go that way anymore, but thats good as too much of it would be just that, too much and become cliche.
Heston dying in the pose of a crusifiction was a master stroke in 'Omega Man' as he signalled the new rise of humanity after its sin. He died for humanity's sin.

You have to remember that if Ridley made the film with Arnold, he would have geared it to suit Arnie's presence and style and it may have worked fantastic.
If it was made in the style and vein of 'End Of Days' or 'Collateral Damage', Scott and Schwarzenegger could well have had a hit.
__________________
"...the movie you see isn't my movie or the director's movie, its the viewer's movie. How they see it and interpret it from what we have done..." Rutger Hauer.
Kinzdone is offline   Reply With Quote